Real-Time Physics Simulation Forum

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-18T16:06:48+00:00

Ok, mystery solved, it turns out the I have msvc 7.1 standard at home and this "does not include an optimizing compiler".

Microsoft is a bunch of dirty thieving robbing bastards ...

I guess I'll have to upgrade to 8.0

Colin

Statistics: Posted by cersoft — Fri Aug 18, 2006 4:06 pm

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T23:26:43+00:00

Hmmm, so I compiled 1.9 at work with useCompound and createConstraint turned off and got

Code:

#cycle; BuildAndProcessIslands; CallbackTriggers; DispatchAllCollisionPairs; SolveConstraint; SyncMotionStates; predictIntegratedTransform; proceedToTransform; 0; 0.009339; 3e-006; 0.002265; 3e-006; 4e-005; 0.000156; 0.000226; 1; 0.009053; 3e-006; 0.002269; 3e-006; 4.2e-005; 0.000156; 0.00022; 2; 0.00892; 3e-006; 0.002319; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000148; 0.000216; 3; 0.009519; 2e-006; 0.002535; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000161; 0.000218; 4; 0.009418; 4e-006; 0.002257; 2e-006; 3.8e-005; 0.000157; 0.000218; 5; 0.013528; 4e-006; 0.002301; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000154; 0.000219; 6; 0.009082; 4e-006; 0.002433; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000153; 0.000232; 7; 0.009138; 3e-006; 0.002266; 3e-006; 5e-005; 0.000153; 0.000218; 8; 0.008899; 3e-006; 0.002421; 2e-006; 4.1e-005; 0.000147; 0.000223; 9; 0.009007; 3e-006; 0.00226; 3e-006; 4.1e-005; 0.000146; 0.000217; 10; 0.009549; 3e-006; 0.002238; 2e-006; 3.9e-005; 0.000144; 0.000218; 11; 0.008898; 3e-006; 0.002259; 3e-006; 4e-005; 0.00016; 0.000217; 12; 0.008785; 3e-006; 0.002427; 3e-006; 4.2e-005; 0.000148; 0.000215; 13; 0.008937; 4e-006; 0.002437; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000147; 0.00024; 14; 0.009237; 3e-006; 0.002237; 2e-006; 4.1e-005; 0.000155; 0.000228; 15; 0.008885; 3e-006; 0.002881; 2e-006; 4e-005; 0.000145; 0.000216; 16; 0.009257; 3e-006; 0.002209; 2e-006; 4.1e-005; 0.000159; 0.000347; 17; 0.008936; 3e-006; 0.002464; 3e-006; 4e-005; 0.000153; 0.00022; 18; 0.008924; 3e-006; 0.002259; 3e-006; 4.2e-005; 0.00016; 0.000218; 19; 0.008851; 3e-006; 0.002376; 2e-006; 4.1e-005; 0.000156; 0.000215;

It's the same compiler in threory (7.1) so I'm gonna check my compile options when I get home and worst case re-install 7.1 ...

Colin

Statistics: Posted by cersoft — Thu Aug 17, 2006 11:26 pm

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T16:28:37+00:00

The timings for ccdPhysicsDemo are as such ...

And the csv pumps out ...

Code:

#cycle; BuildAndProcessIslands; CallbackTriggers; DispatchAllCollisionPairs; SolveConstraint; SyncMotionStates; predictIntegratedTransform; proceedToTransform; 0; 0.060212; 1e-006; 0.02502; 0.000244; 8.8e-005; 0.000456; 0.001042; 1; 0.06027; 2e-006; 0.025045; 0.000256; 8.8e-005; 0.000344; 0.000951; 0.004985; 2; 0.058946; 7e-006; 0.025055; 0.000244; 8.3e-005; 0.000342; 0.001046; 0.00483; 3; 0.060131; 2e-006; 0.025136; 0.000249; 8.9e-005; 0.000342; 0.000952; 0.004731; 4; 0.059192; 2e-006; 0.025235; 0.000271; 8.8e-005; 0.000344; 0.001014; 0.004823; 5; 0.06066; 3e-006; 0.028412; 0.000245; 8.1e-005; 0.000335; 0.001008; 0.004697; 6; 0.060868; 2e-006; 0.02524; 0.00024; 8.9e-005; 0.000339; 0.001842; 0.00468; 7; 0.06027; 2e-006; 0.024839; 0.000239; 8.7e-005; 0.000337; 0.000958; 0.00474; 8; 0.060511; 7e-006; 0.025194; 0.000318; 8.9e-005; 0.000429; 0.001052; 0.004671; 9; 0.060119; 1e-006; 0.02504; 0.000238; 8.8e-005; 0.000341; 0.000976; 0.004741; 10; 0.062397; 2e-006; 0.025162; 0.000239; 8.2e-005; 0.000342; 0.000968; 0.00477; 11; 0.06041; 2e-006; 0.02491; 0.000244; 8.8e-005; 0.000427; 0.001043; 0.004686; 12; 0.05939; 2e-006; 0.025071; 0.000292; 0.000103; 0.00034; 0.001008; 0.004765; 13; 0.05986; 2e-006; 0.024959; 0.000321; 8.8e-005; 0.000344; 0.000958; 0.004668; 14; 0.060661; 1e-006; 0.025068; 0.000248; 8.3e-005; 0.000348; 0.000962; 0.004743; 15; 0.063542; 2e-006; 0.027765; 0.000244; 8.7e-005; 0.000346; 0.000963; 0.005065; 16; 0.087222; 1e-006; 0.067971; 0.00046; 9.4e-005; 0.000576; 0.002024; 0.004916; 17; 0.061004; 2e-006; 0.024941; 0.000244; 8.6e-005; 0.000344; 0.000973; 0.005008; 18; 0.059588; 2e-006; 0.025145; 0.000244; 8.6e-005; 0.000342; 0.001058; 0.004657; 19; 0.059918; 2e-006; 0.024998; 0.000252; 8.4e-005; 0.000345; 0.000962; 0.004838; 20; 0.061607; 2e-006; 0.025345; 0.000239; 8.4e-005; 0.000345; 0.000965; 0.004874; 21; 0.060149; 1e-006; 0.030098; 0.000262; 8.8e-005; 0.000349; 0.000954; 0.004919;

So as far as I can see, BuildProcessIslands and DispatchAllCollisionPairs are taking much more time ...

Colin

Statistics: Posted by cersoft — Thu Aug 17, 2006 4:28 pm

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T09:29:22+00:00

So all the precompiled demos run fast?

I don't have rar / windows machine to check it out at the moment.
So the CcdPhysicsDemo is very slow too? There is some profiling info that you can enable to locate the problem.

See LinearMath/quickprof.h and uncomment the USE_QUICKPROF define:

Code:

#define USE_QUICKPROF 1

Then run CcdPhysicsDemo and press 'p' key. This shows some statistics on screen. Also it creates a .csv file with the statistics, each time you press toggle p to enable stats. Press 'd' to disable deactivation to get best timings. You might need to add extra timers to locate the slowdown. For example, add a block around the 'renderme()' call, around line 734 in CcdPhysicsDemo.cpp:

Code:

#ifdef USE_QUICKPROF        Profiler::beginBlock("render");#endif //USE_QUICKPROFrenderme();#ifdef USE_QUICKPROF        Profiler::endBlock("render");#endif

Notice that you cannot nest the beginBlock/endBlock. You can add one in the CcdPhysicsDemo.cpp to profile graphics drawing. Just dont add one around the proceedDeltaTime call.

Perhaps it's just some graphics feature that is horribly slow, like line/wireframe or text drawing drawing'. Try 'h' key, to disable text.

On the Macbook Pro typical timings are like:
BuildProcessIslands: 0.01
DispatchAllCollisionPairs: 0.004
render: 0.005

Can you give your timings?
Thanks,
Erwin

Statistics: Posted by Erwin Coumans — Thu Aug 17, 2006 9:29 am

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T08:35:30+00:00

Do they run slower then the precompiled demos on the Download page?

What machine do you have? Which demo in particular?
Did you try BspDemo?
Thanks,
Erwin

Absolutely, check the compiled version of bspDemo at http://creed.angeltowns.net/newVideos/BspDemo.rar

I have a P4 3.4Ghz with ATI 9800 pro

Statistics: Posted by cersoft — Thu Aug 17, 2006 8:35 am

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T07:50:46+00:00

Do they run slower then the precompiled demos on the Download page?

What machine do you have? Which demo in particular?
Did you try BspDemo?
Thanks,
Erwin

Statistics: Posted by Erwin Coumans — Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:50 am

Compiled demos running really slowly

2006-08-17T07:12:26+00:00

So, I downloaded 1.9 source and compiled a release version on VC 7.1 and the demos run super slow, does anyone know of this issue and if so how to fix it?

Thanks in advance

Colin

Statistics: Posted by cersoft — Thu Aug 17, 2006 7:12 am